The Naturally Social Science Writer

Share this post

Narcissism in the Guise of Animal Rights Activism

www.drjordanschaulmedia.com
A Look at Wildlife with Dr. Michael Hutchins

Narcissism in the Guise of Animal Rights Activism

Reflections on Conversations with the Late Michael Hutchins, PhD - Wildlife Conservation and Welfare Expert

Jordan Schaul PhD
Jun 25, 2022
1
Share this post

Narcissism in the Guise of Animal Rights Activism

www.drjordanschaulmedia.com

Jordan Schaul | Scapegoat Strength | A Look at Wildlife w/ Dr. Michael Hutchins

I was reminded today of conversations I had with my late friend and mentor Dr. Michael Hutchins. Dr. Hutchins was a zoo biology pioneer, renowned wildlife scientist, and nonprofit executive. A protégé of the late Dr. William Conway, Hutchins was an innovative and inspiring figure in the field of nature conservation.

He held the endowed William Conway Chair of Conservation and Science for the Association of Zoos and Aquariums before becoming CEO of the Wildlife Society. In my commemorative tribute to his life and career, I reflected on how many people Dr. Hutchins influenced in the fields of conservation and applied animal welfare science. His work spanned the globe and impacted generations of conservation-minded enthusiasts and professionals. His legacy carries on with the Dr. Michael Hutchins Impact on Wildlife Fund, which was established by his wife Song Hutchins.

Hutchins’ skillful diplomacy allowed him to work effectively with a diverse and eclectic group of natural resource stakeholders, including indigenous communities, trophy hunters, and federal officials.

He was able to navigate intra-institutional politics and inter-institutional relations because of a strong acumen for the human dimension of conservation science and management.

Hutchins’ ability to work with a polarized demographic on highly politicized issues was conferred by his empathy and appreciation for the human condition. His understanding of a new and multidisciplinary field and its application made him a guru of sorts and he liaised and mediated between and among people in conflict who otherwise had little in common.

The cognitive distortions of animal rights activists

In our discussions about animal ethics, Dr. Hutchins often mentioned that animal rights extremists often harbor misplaced compassion. I will say that they may also exhibit savior or hero narcissism. Unfortunately, these activists approach an ethical dilemma through a cognitive distortion, which I describe below. As a friend and colleague pointed out, “Any extremist has this capacity.” But I argue that choosing to save animals under the pretense of love and out of spite for other people is not love at all.

It is easy to anoint oneself as the protector of the voiceless because animals have no say in accepting or rejecting a human’s position. In this regard, heroism often confers power and control over sentient species in the guise of concern, compassion, and advocacy. In many cases, activists lack empathy for people but presume to empathize with the plight of animals in need. This is a controversial stance to take.

Narcissism and hate

I’m always suspicious of those who exhibit such disdain and contempt for humans but claim to love other species. Narcissists spend a lot of time comparing themselves to others. Their insecurity is driven by internal shame and is externalized as rage and expressed as hate. In the case of animal rights activists, their vitriol directed toward other people is stronger than their purported love for animals.

Animal activists are like narcissistic parents

The narcissistic animal activist compares to the narcissistic parent who responds inappropriately to narcissistic injury. These parents are much quicker to defend their fragile ego when their child (perceived as an extension of themself) is insulted or humiliated. The parent who goes on the attack rather than to the aid of their emotionally or physically harmed offspring is the parent who succumbs to a fragile ego. Nurturing parents should instinctively respond to their child's immediate needs regarding distress and not be consumed with the perpetrator.

The instinct of the emotionally healthy parent is to protect and support their children.
Unfortunately, my experience with animal rights activists is that they are more consumed with defensive and offensive posturing and much less with the immediate needs of animals they so readily claim to care about.

This is the distinction between the empirical orientation of the animal welfarist and the cognitive distortion of the activist harboring unresolved trauma. The former is focused on the well-being of the animal and the latter is consumed with self-loathing cloaked in a misguided desire to be a savior.

More on cognitive distortions

Extremists tend to be dichotomous thinkers as opposed to dialectical ones. Looking through the world through an all-or-nothing lens is a common cognitive distortion that stems from childhood trauma and splitting behavior. To be continued….

The Accidental Science Writer
Human-Wildlife Conflict
By Jordan Schaul | National Geographic | March 9, 2013 (Citations Embedded) In our fifth interview in a series on environmental issues, Dr. Michael Hutchins and I explore human-wildlife interactions from a global perspective. In his responses to my questions, the noted wildlife biologist provides an array of examples of conflict, solutions to some of the…
Read more
a year ago · Jordan Schaul PhD
The Accidental Science Writer
The Climate Change Conundrum
By Jordan Schaul | National Geographic | January 10, 2013 (Citations Embedded) Contributing Editor Dr. Jordan Schaul and distinguished wildlife biologist and professor Dr. Michael Hutchins discuss the current and anticipated impact of climate change on wildlife species around the globe in an exclusive Nat Geo News Watch interview…
Read more
a year ago · Jordan Schaul PhD
The Accidental Science Writer
On the Brink of Extinction: A Closer Look at Endangered Species
By Jordan Schaul | National Geographic | April 5, 2013 (Citations Embedded) Many naturalists and certainly most birding aficionados are well aware that the last passenger pigeon died in 1914 while in residence at the Cincinnati Zoo. And I regretfully acknowledge that the last wild passenger pigeon was shot in 1900 in my home state of Ohio. The Zoo’s pa…
Read more
a year ago · Jordan Schaul PhD
The Accidental Science Writer
Evolutionary Perspectives & Approaches to Conserving Vanishing Wildlife
By Jordan Schaul | National Geographic | April 20, 2013 In prior interviews with Dr. Michael Hutchins, we discussed the impact of threats such as emerging infectious diseases and invasive species on extant wildlife populations. In recent times, many species have not fared well in the face of such threats, and in some cases have been rendered extinct in …
Read more
a year ago · Jordan Schaul PhD
The Accidental Science Writer
Cognitive Distortion: Dichotomous Thinking
By Dr. Jordan Schaul | Scapegoat Strength | October 5, 2021 Have you ever been ‘love bombed’ and then thrown off the ‘pedestal’ by a friend, partner or colleague? Have you had a bad week and thought you couldn’t do anything right? Have you blamed someone else for doing everything wrong? If these behaviors and experiences reflect a pattern, you may have…
Read more
a year ago · 1 like · Jordan Schaul PhD


Share this post

Narcissism in the Guise of Animal Rights Activism

www.drjordanschaulmedia.com
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Jordan Carlton Schaul
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing